What classics do you want to see reviewed?

Goat

I did say that I'd like MR to be the foremost Metal resource online. Covering everything of Metallica's seems like a good first step, no?

ganeshaRules

Zad wrote
I did say that I'd like MR to be the foremost Metal resource online. Covering everything of Metallica's seems like a good first step, no?

Yes... now let's do it with maiden, judas & black sabbath.

And I can't write in this section withput repeating: Angel witch, Angel Witch!

Mintrude

ganeshaRules wrote
Zad wrote
I did say that I'd like MR to be the foremost Metal resource online. Covering everything of Metallica's seems like a good first step, no?
Yes... now let's do it with maiden, judas & black sabbath.

Agreed. Have Maiden not been done yet?

Goat

Mintrude wrote
ganeshaRules wrote
Zad wrote
I did say that I'd like MR to be the foremost Metal resource online. Covering everything of Metallica's seems like a good first step, no?
Yes... now let's do it with maiden, judas & black sabbath.
Agreed. Have Maiden not been done yet?

The first couple are yet to be done, I know that much.

Mintrude

Zad wrote
Mintrude wrote
ganeshaRules wrote
Zad wrote
I did say that I'd like MR to be the foremost Metal resource online. Covering everything of Metallica's seems like a good first step, no?
Yes... now let's do it with maiden, judas & black sabbath.
Agreed. Have Maiden not been done yet?
The first couple are yet to be done, I know that much.

Ah right. Not enough of a Maiden fan to do 'em though. Definitely will go to work on a few of the Sabbaths though.

Thrashtildeth

How about one of the first 4 Testament albums? Any one would make me happy, but if im going to get specific, even though The Legacy is probably the most likely choice, I would argue Practice What You Preach is more deserving.

And maybe...uh...Kreator's Coma of Souls? I like my thrash agressive and technical as you can plainly see...

Goat

Thrashtilldeth wrote
How about one of the first 4 Testament albums? Any one would make me happy, but if im going to get specific, even though The Legacy is probably the most likely choice, I would argue Practice What You Preach is more deserving.And maybe...uh...Kreator's Coma of Souls? I like my thrash agressive and technical as you can plainly see...

Pracise What You Preach has been done.

Thrashtildeth

Aw heck, since I'm already at it, I'll also suggest Heathen's Victims of Deception. And maybe even Doomsday for the Deceiver by Flotsam and Jetsam?

Thrashtildeth

Zad wrote
Thrashtilldeth wrote
How about one of the first 4 Testament albums? Any one would make me happy, but if im going to get specific, even though The Legacy is probably the most likely choice, I would argue Practice What You Preach is more deserving.And maybe...uh...Kreator's Coma of Souls? I like my thrash agressive and technical as you can plainly see...
Pracise What You Preach has been done.

Oh...sorry bout that. The Legacy it is!

traptunderice

I like The New Order better than Legacy.

The_Voice

Thrashtilldeth wrote
Aw heck, since I'm already at it, I'll also suggest Heathen's Victims of Deception. And maybe even Doomsday for the Deceiver by Flotsam and Jetsam?

Yes both albums deserves a review Classic or not.

Now playing: October 31 - No Survivors
via FoxyTunes

noodles

Protest the Hero - Kezia definitely

traptunderice

noodles wrote
Protest the Hero - Kezia definitely

As a classic? No.

Legacy_Of_The_Night

traptunderice wrote
noodles wrote
Protest the Hero - Kezia definitely
As a classic? No.

At least not yet. It's only been about 2 years, we don't know what impact it's had at this point.

ganeshaRules

Thrashtilldeth wrote
AAnd maybe even Doomsday for the Deceiver by Flotsam and Jetsam?

Not sure about classic, but hell yeah to an archive review. And No place for disgrace, too. (The current F&J reviews don't show the real level of the band)

skeetkatz

Symphony X - The Divine Wings Of Tragedy

Symphony X has been so influential its a shame none of their earlier albums have been reviewed.

Goat

skeetkatz wrote
Symphony X - The Divine Wings Of TragedySymphony X has been so influential its a shame none of their earlier albums have been reviewed.

That's actually the only S-X album I own.

Thrashtildeth

Whoa....

I just realised that South of Heaven hasn't even got a review!

I'd call it classic, but it deserves an archive review at the VERY least!

Skeksis

Gorguts - The Erosion Of Sanity

in fact the only Gorguts review on this site is very poor, not to do with the score or anything, but the writing is horrible. I mean, read this:

<a class="postlink" href="http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=768">http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=768</a>

The result of their first album Obscura was kind of a fascination in the death scene.

Obscura was their third album.

And the reviewer said their genre was "Morbid Angel copycat". wtf?

Goat

Skeksis wrote
Gorguts - The Erosion Of Sanityin fact the only Gorguts review on this site is very poor, not to do with the score or anything, but the writing is horrible. I mean, read this:<a class="postlink" href="http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=768">http://www.metalreviews.com/reviews/detail.php3?id=768</a>[quote]The result of their first album Obscura was kind of a fascination in the death scene.

Obscura was their third album.And the reviewer said their genre was "Morbid Angel copycat". wtf?[/quote]Some of the old reviews here are just... just pretend they don't exist. I mean,

It is quiet ok to develop a fascination and respect for a cult band like Morbid Angel but in fact Gorguts are loosing their identity or maybe trying to find one.

just makes me quiver with a raging urge to correct the spelling.

« Previous Page Next Page »