I just got this one. It's pretty good, but I haven't given it a full listen yet. I definitely don't like the guitar tone, though. It's too clean and processed; I prefer a more organic, straight into the amp, live sound.
I guess I'm a Dream Theater and Opeth fanboy. At least I'm not a Meshuggah fanboy though; they haven't written a new riff since Destroy, Erase, Improve. It's just the same damn riff on chugga chugga 8-string guitars in slightly different time signatures, along with lame solos that have NO sense of melody or structure. I never understood the term wankery until I heard recent Meshuggah.
I also wouldn't say that Opeth are more overrated than, say, the dozens of derivative, poorly produced black metal bands that get 90+ scores on this site. :wink: