noodles wroteThe lists tend to be a mush of influence/skill/popularity/reviewer's personal favourites/etc, but it's hard to move beyond that in an objective way. I'm not really a fan of Clapton and Page either but I can see why they get on the lists 'cause even I know a handful of Led Zeppelin and Cream riffs.Look on the bright side: you have a wife you can debate lists of guitarists with! π
I'm very happy and lucky that I'm married to a woman who knows her music so that we can discuss these sorts of issues. I do understand that Page has written some unforgettable riffs and songs but my argument is that a ton of other guitarists have done the same and don't receive a fraction of the adulation that he garners. As for Clapton, yes the riff for Layla is very cool but I don't think that 'I Shot The Sheriff', 'Cocaine', or 'Tears In Heaven' have ever inspired anyone to pick up a guitar.
My other complaint centers around the buffoons that Rolling Stone mailed ballots out to. I mean they asked two guys from 'My Morning Jacket' to participate in the voting. C'mon!! I find that all validity is in question solely because they asked Mick Mars for his opinion. :lol: