cry of the banshee wrote:
traptunderice wrote:
cry of the banshee wrote:
RecklessNightmare wrote:
cry of the banshee wrote:
RecklessNightmare wrote:
Here's my (female) perspective:
It doesn't matter what you do with your time. Knitting? Bring it on. Gender roles are ridiculous anyway. As long as you're confident. Attitude is the deal breaker.
Also, if a girl kisses someone else... I don't think she should get any additional chances. Unless circumstances were incredibly aberrant, chances are that if she's done it once she'll do it again.
Being constrained by whatever gender roles society dictates may or may not be ridiculous, but correct me if I'm wrong: females generally seek out the alphas in the group, no? Mating in many ways is a competition for resources, for want of a better metaphor,
the historical/anthropological reasons being fairly well known and established.
Even highly successful women rarely mate with males that are lower down on the pecking order than they are.
Yes, that's true. But you can be the alpha and partake in whatever activities you want. It's not the gender roles themselves, it's your attitude about them. How masculine can you look while playing the piccolo? If the answer is a confident "very much so" then go for it. If the answer is "well... I don't know.." Then you might want to hold off.
Again, confidence is what really matters.
That sounds reasonable enough.
One of the defining traits (if not THE defining trait) of the alpha is definitely self confidence.
I think the whole knitting thing stems mainly from it being that this is a site that is dedicated to discussion of things metal related, more or less, and metal is generally associated with machismo, virility, aggression and other so-called "masculine" traits. (I am in no way implying that metal isn't "a girl thing"; on the contrary it is nice to see females amongst the ranks). But traditionally, it's a genre that is overwhelmingly male oriented.
Knitting and such is generally associated with little old ladies, and just seems out of place.
Because covering your face in paint and wearing eye liner or having long hair are tried and true signifiers of machismo.
Yes, because that is representative of all metal throughout history...
got something subsatantial to add, or is this going to be another typical trapt false dichotomy?
Let me know, so I can avoid wasting my time.
You're just trying to paint a very diverse category as one solidified, homogenous realm. It doesn't matter whether those instances were representative of all metal throughout history; they challenge the narrative that you're making that all metal throughout history has been about a hardened masculinity.
Arguing with you is worthless, but I'll say this. A lot of people that I know who listen to metal got into it due to issues at home. It's a way of responding to bickering parents, alcoholics in the house, etc, if not full-on domestic abuse. A lot of those issues point back to, at least for me, masculinity and aggression. If there was ever a place to counter that or resist that it ought to be fucking metal. Get the final word, V, and we'll call it quits.