Metal Reviews

Vigilante should only have 2 attempts through the game, the strategy will increase a lot, and the suicide option is excellent.

Talking like a true mafioso!

C'mon, that would balance enormously the game. Having the power to kill one person every night was just too much for only one character. The seer was an interesting role, a shame that he didn't know what to do with the info

What if the seer could be either an innocent, a blood brother or the bodyguard?
Not a mafioso or the vigilante, that would be too easy...

I prefer the seer, the blood brother & the seer as different people... Just because being innocent without powers is boring...

I'd like more minor powers for innocent people...

The blood brothers are sort of useless.

better than being just innocent.

Yeah, everyone should have some minor power at least.

Be just as much use making up roles like 'the dumb blonde' 'the nerdy girl' 'the goth' and having people respond according to their characters. The trouble with this game was that people voted others off based around how much they posted, and once the noisy ones like me and ftr were gone, it was less balanced.

As the mad inquisitor, the impulsive pet vendor or the suspicious smith? XD

Agreed on the minor powers for the innocents. Besides, every person should have a role, like a smith, bartender, trader, witch, druid, paladin, pawnbroker, etc. And everyone should post according to its character. In every town, some people know who the mafia are and they doesn't care, so maybe one innocent minor power is to know one mafia member, and use that info for their convenience, maybe he can trade that information for his life, if he's targeted by the mob.

Also, every participant must make a minimum of 5 posts a day.

It can't be too complex, but people have to get involved more.

It's starting to sound like an RPG.

Also, there shouldn't be a requirement of posts per day, just don't sign up if you can't be somewhat active.

I insist that there should be a necromancer class and the zombies could also kill one person each night, or maybe the cult leader could have the ability to do so.

I say drop the cult leader add zombies and a necromancer. No post requirements.

Being a blood brother wasn't bad. I felt better knowing Edge was good. It got better as the game went on.

@Zad: If we weren't voting on how people posted, then what were we supposed to look for. You and ftr were trying to lead other players.

I'm so not posting in character.
That's ridiculously gay.
Who do you think I am!

I really agree with the x amounts of post per day notion though. It really became unfair.

What do you people have against RPG ?

I like the ideas of zombies killing people! Brrraaaaaaaiiiiinnnnssss!!!

You always post in character anyways Car.

A zombie class might be interesting. Each night, the necromancer can raise one dead person as a zombie, which can then infect others... bit daft though: OH WHO IS THE ZOMBIE OH WHO COULD IT POSSIBLY BE

yeah that wouldn't work too well :\