Quote:
It is not ridiculous. But I wasn't specific enough about it either. The law was also made to avoid arranged marriages to be used to bringing families together across boarders. Typical a girl would be married to her cousin from the middle east in these marriages. Second of all, it only applies to immigrants and ppl outside EU.
Banning arranged marriages itself would be kinda hard. How would one detect weither or not it is the case? Agencies can't do shit either. Before anybody would find out it would already be too late, and how exactly would one help her out? The 24-law is much more effecient, it's easy to follow and the number of arranged marriages has declined so far.
Now you have described it in greater detail it makes more sense to me.

However there is a big difference between this and what you first described, and it seems to have as much to do with keeping people out as stopping arranged marriages. Nonetheless I do understand the point you are making.
But I don't necessarily see the same flaws in the agencies idea that you do- surely the idea would be that a woman who knew she was going to be forced into marriage would contact BEFORE it was too late. What can the govt. do? Well, if it can ban immigrants a whole group of people from getting married then it can act in individual cases as well. Of course there are problems, such as the potential for "retaliation" on the part of the parents against the woman that contacted said agency. But then with the 24-year model no doubt there is similar, and maybe even worse cases. Girls being dragged off to foreign countries to marry etc...
Quote:
I didn't meant teenagers were wearing burqas. I meant scarfs in general. Those girls who doesn't wear scarf and burqas are typical ppl who care less about their religion. You can be a muslim in many ways. Girls will typical be a reflection of her parents. As i also stated earlier: where western parents gives their children more freedom as they grow old, muslim parents tends to limit that freedom - no partying, dating etc. This means, that when you have put them in a scarf or burka they are less likely to take it off again
Hmm, I am really not remotely sure about this- upon what do you base the idea that Muslim girls are less likely to adopt a different lifestyle to their parents?
Quote:
We have no assimilation policies. To be assimilated means to give up everything and embrace another culture. However, when muslim children grow up in danish sociaty they are most likely to be very danish-sized. This does however not mean they start to eat pork or drink beer, or that they have been modified to be the exact same. We only have a few criterias or expectations so to speak: Learn danish, and agree with certain values/principles in our sociaty.
But from your posts here it seems to me that you want to extend societies values and principles to include dictating what people can and cannot wear.
Quote:
You cannot start your argument with: " I am not wrong, because I find it inconceivable...", that's not a proof of anything. You're right, though, but wrong in your conception on our country.
We have not told them to take of their burka by means of legislations, there's been a great debate about it scarfs with alot of muslims envolved in it as well, muslims that was pro, of course. However, they did not mention anything about that it was their own choice - but despite of that i still approve scarfs in public, except in the government. Weither or not their boss at work would approve it would have to be up to them.
But that is exactly the point I was making; Christian or atheist Danes and Muslims shall likely continue to get along better WITHOUT the need for clumsy and arbitrary government edicts upon people's behaviour, such as banning items of clothing. You were saying I was wrong, because Muslims were integrating into Danish society. The point I made was that sure, they may well be, but what makes you think this is anything to do with banning items of clothing, rather than just the fact that both groups are humans with plenty in common anyway.
Quote:
It is a matter of education, and so far no girl wearing a burqa has ever set her foot on the university or gymnasium. You can then wonder about if she is kept at home by her family, or has become enlightened in the process
And yes, fundamentaly i think muslim are just as normal as everybody else. I believe that every human being is striving towards freedom, unfortunately many are under the influence of religion and suppressive cultures. Saw a documentry from Iran a while ago, with some muslim men and women living in the city who dreamed about freedom as well, or rather a country as it used to be. In Iran you don't have freedom of speech, free market, and you can't hold hands or date in public etc etc, and then there was all that bullshit about women that are treated like trash if they date in the first place, and how they had to wear a scarf whenever they went outside, despite hating it, despite being non-religious. However, even in Iran there are lot's of progressive forces moving underneath, and they are just as horny as everybody else and listen to the same crappy pop-music, some places that is. Education and knowledge is power, the reason why women in burqas are kept away from said same thing. You are of course, welcome to show me proof that women wearing burkas are just as educated as everybody else, and that more than a handfull chosed themselves, cuz there are exceptions in every aspect of life.
Well, I know you are right about social currents in Iran, that is very true. But then it isn't especially relevant to this discussion. I am saying it's wrong to force people to dress in a certain way, and it is also wrong to force people not to dress in a certain way.
As far as education goes, the burkha is more likely a symptom than a cause. Banning it would solve nothing in that regard. Plus, I
have seen Muslim women in burkhas in British universities, and not just a handful of exceptions here and there, fairly regularly, in fact.
Aaagh... I have to take issue with some of this next part.
Quote:
Are you sure your comfortable stereotypical view on me or my country is even correct?! National bullshit is not about making other ppl bending to your will, is it?
Not talking about your country, I am talking about "Nationalistic bullshit" that occurs in every country across the entire world. The ranting about "respecting our culture" is EXACTLY the same wherever you may go. What you were saying in your earlier posts along these lines is nothing I haven't heard 1000 times before in the UK.
Quote:
The funny thing is, you have implied that your country/culture is better than mine, while attacking me for not wanting certain foreign cultural elements in mine. Isn't that hypocrisy?
Except I clearly didn't; firstly because I was talking about a very specific issue- not something as broad as "culture", and secondly, because I was criticizing issues of policy, not national character.
Quote:
To your last post i can only say that, some ppl care about the future of their culture, others are so open minded and tolerant that they forget about themselves - become blind to certain problem areas that could be improved or solved, certain elements that never should be.
I can't see why I'm not allowed to be concearned about certain muslim groups not being fully integrated, the biggest problem group, or treat to our sociaty/culture is still the radical muslims, though. But this group also has a link to the burka group, hereby not saying that women wearing burqas are the radical ones or pose any threat as such. If you don't integrate, you are not a part of a sociaty and don't contribute to its preservation.
As if Danish culture is like a fairy that will die if you don't fully profess your belief in it and love for it at every turn. The biggest threat to your society and culture is not anything to do with Muslims- these are a scapegoat, and terrorism is an abstraction. The biggest problems in society are consumerism, corporate bullying, an unsustainable level of global inequality, a complete lack of public influence over government unless it comes in a form filtered through the eyes of the corporate media, the military complex.... Instead people prefer to worry about something that is very ill defined- "national culture"- disappearing because some people that live on the same patch of earth as them dress differently and have diffrent beliefs. If you believe in Danishness, then you can raise your kids to, and if it is really worth preserving then enough people will do so for it to survive.