NewFriendAncientEnemy wrote:
Marty say's join the team. I tried. No go. Furthermore, I don't see how reviewing a band is declaring open season, and having a say in how MR is run. That's stupid. An unmention band, reviewed, in a forum thread, is just as good a discussion opener as anything. To say anything about bandwidth is retarded. Opening a discussion thread with a review of the band would give your stance on them, as well as introduce newbies who can't discuss otherwise. Veterans of the band could give their own opinion, like they always do in the reviews forum. All in all, it's be an AMAZINGLY productive way to start discussions. I'm not reading any further into that thread, because anyone saying anything otherwise would be absolute bullshit to read, and on top of that, confusing. So re-read my post, and answer my question. CAN I POST REVIEWS H-E-R-E?
So you didn't read everything then? If so, how can you demand I answer your question?
Let's put it in perspective, I asked the question and was shot down by Marty I believe, he misinterpreted my intention when I jokingly made a demand. The bandwidth issue is not an issue as long as you use small images hosted elsewhere, which is why I suggested allmusic.com.
The big issue to the long time reviewers here is that posting long reviews just like they do on the main site sort of undermines the intentions of the site. Can you not see that point? I can. I'm not saying that now because I'm a reviewer now, I said it then as well.
Here is my suggestion, post reviews like this:
TWILIGHT OPHERA - THE END OF THE HALYCON AGE
Nordic black metal from Finland, or something like that! The good thing about this CD is that the singer has more of a melodic death metal voice and not the higher register rasping of a lot of black metal bands, the music is also much more dynamic than your traditional black metal outfit utilizing a variety of musical styles, instrumentation and song structures to break up the monotony that plagues many bands in this genre. There is also clean male and female vocals interspersed throughout the CD, and with elements of power metal, traditional metal and gothic rock this CD comes highly recommended! And I'm usually no fan of black metal.
This is simple and to the point. Try not to review albums that other people may review here, as well. There is a core group of reviewers here that have been here for a long time, if they ask that forum members don't do full-blown reviews, then don't. Do short reviews like the one above, it will still generate discussion if that is what you're after.