Blind Guardian - A Night At The Opera
Guardian Of Metal
10 songs (67'00)
Release year: 2002
Blind Guardian, Virgin
Reviewed by Danny
Album of the year

My throat is tight, my heart beats faster, my hands suddenly become sweaty as my finger hit the play button. The new Blind Guardian has arrived !!! At the end of the first play, I immediately realize that many spins will be required to find the key of the new Bards world. Today, after many spins, I can tell you that this new Blind Guardian album .... is their best ever effort as A Night At The Opera will stay in the history of metal forever.

I don't know how many messages I will receive for that, but I am not a huge fan of their previous work (Nightfall In Middle-Earth) and this is the main reason why I refused to write a review on it. I am a Blind Guardian's fan almost since their beginning and I considered Imaginations From The Other Side & Tales From The Twilight World as their best albums ... until this one of course.

Yes I found Nightfall In Middle-Earth too progressive, too "commercial" and less heavy compare to all their previous records. Welcome To Dying, The Last Candle, Lost In The Twilight Hall, Imaginations From The Other Side or Bright Eyes (all songs) seem so far and only Mirror, Mirror was saving the previous record. Today I admit that without Nightfall In Middle-Earth, A Night At The Opera would never have seen the light and I found myself finally "understanding better" Nightfall In Middle-Earth. It was a step, a natural step, a necessary step that was opening the door to this magnificent, this jewel, this masterpiece, this killer, this never-done-before, this "you-can-throw-away-all-your-other-metal-cds" called A Night At The Opera.

I could write 200 pages per song, PER SONG !!! And don't ask me to choose one from another ... as it will be an insult to the one I will not quote. Everything on this Opera kills : the fast guitar riffs, the progressive breaks, the unbelievable voice of Hansi (what a singer !), the enormous production of Charlie Bauerfeind, the drums (what a drum sound my friends !), the keyboard and orchestral effects. Yes, every single note kills ;-))

What the hell can I say about Precious Jerusalem (1st track), Battlefield (2th track) or The Soulforged (7th track) ? I could say that previous Blind Guardian's chorus were miserable. What the hell can I say about The Maiden And The Minstrel Knight (5th track) or Punishment Divine (9th track) ? I could say that the orchestration of Nightfall In Middle-Earth or Imaginations From The Other Side are "rocky-games" compare to what you will have the chance to hear very soon. Under The Ice (3rd Track) is a classic amongst the classics and Sadly Sings Destiny (4th track) sees Blind Guardian trying new things, new elements ... and totally succeeding on this new path. And I am forgetting Wait For An Answer (6th track) which is impossible ... to describe, you have to discover it by your own.

I warned you with the single And Then There Was Silence, Blind Guardian is unpredictable and believe me this song has nothing to do with the full album, absolutely nothing. If you like And Then There Was Silence (being fantastic of course), I can't find the right words I should use to describe you the remaining 9 songs, as such arrangement and orchestration have never been made (heard) before. As I am listening to the cd for the hundred times while writing this review, I still discover here and there unbelievable structures and melodies ... and I am wondering if I was deaf when I listen to it ... just an hour ago. And it grows, it grows, it grows inside you like an alien. Well in other words, the kind of CD you bring with you on a lost island.

The bad thing here (if I can say so), is that I cannot change CD now ... as the rest is tasteless, totally tasteless. I am stick on this record and God knows how many time it will take me before I can "afford" another metal cd. Whether you like heavy, true, thrash, progressive, black or death metal, don't call yourself metal fan anymore if you don't buy this masterpiece, this is simple as that. I could bet a fortune that this will be the best metal album of 2002. I guess you got the point ;-))

Blind Guardian ... who said 'Metal Guardian' ? These guys will explode Wacken 2002 ... and I will miss that for nothing.

Killing Songs :
You will be killed by the whole CD, trust me ;-)
Danny quoted 100 / 100
Chris quoted 100 / 100
Mike quoted 100 / 100
Other albums by Blind Guardian that we have reviewed:
Blind Guardian - Beyond the Red Mirror reviewed by Goat and quoted 90 / 100
Blind Guardian - Somewhere Far Beyond reviewed by Goat and quoted CLASSIC
Blind Guardian - At The Edge Of Time reviewed by Kyle and quoted 86 / 100
Blind Guardian - Follow The Blind reviewed by Goat and quoted 86 / 100
Blind Guardian - A Voice In The Dark (CD Single) reviewed by Marty and quoted no quote
To see all 16 reviews click here
67 readers voted
Your quote was: 100.
Change your vote

There are no replies yet to this review
Be the first one to post a reply!